Welcome to The Bagel Shop of Cape May
Experience the taste of authentic NY-style bagels right here in Cape May. Our family-owned shop brings you five generations of bagel baking tradition. All bagels are made on premises throughout the day to ensure a hot, fresh bagel is ready when you walk through the door. We use fresh, local, organic ingredients and we offer a wide variety of bagels, homemade cream cheeses and salads, sandwiches, coffees, and a full market of items to go.
Local Favorites
-
Bagel With Your Favorite Topping
Select from our delicious bagel varieties and top with our homemade cream cheese spreads, nut and seed butters.
-
Smoked Nova Special
Your choice of bagel with smoked Nova salmon, tomato, red onion, capers, and your choice of cream cheese.
-
Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich
Your choice of bagel with two large organic eggs, melted America cheese, and your choice of meat (bacon, turkey bacon, sausage, or pork roll)
-
Homemade Deli Salads
Choose from chicken, tuna, or egg salad, freshly prepared in-house.
-
Cold Brew Coffee
Smooth and refreshing, brewed cold for a rich flavor.
-
See the Full Menu & Order Online
Five Generations of Bagel Baking Tradition
Our family has been crafting authentic NY-style bagels for five generations. We bring traditional methods to Cape May, boiling our bagels first and then baking them on burlap for that perfect texture and flavor. Being family-owned, we take pride in every bagel we make, ensuring quality and authenticity in every bite.
What Our Customers Are Saying
